Best Payroll Companies in the USA for 2025: Compare Top Providers

Introduction

Managing payroll in the United States can be complex, especially with compliance requirements, tax obligations, and employee classifications. Whether you’re a startup, SME, or large corporation, choosing the right payroll provider can save time, reduce errors, and ensure peace of mind.

In this guide, we present an updated list of payroll companies in the USA for 2025. Each provider has been selected based on reliability, scalability, compliance support, and customer satisfaction.

Why Use a Payroll Company?

Payroll service providers handle essential tasks such as:

• Salary and wage calculation
• Direct deposit and tax withholding
• Federal and state tax filing
• Benefits integration (healthcare, 401k, etc.)
• Time tracking and employee self-service portals

Using a trusted payroll provider not only reduces administrative burden but also ensures your business stays compliant with labor and tax laws.

Best Payroll Companies in the USA for 2025: Compare Top Providers

Choosing the right payroll provider in the United States is critical for businesses of all sizes — from startups managing their first hires to enterprises with distributed teams. Below is a curated list of top-rated payroll companies in the U.S., including key features, ideal use cases, and partner links for HR leaders ready to streamline their payroll process.

1. Gusto

Bonus: $100 bonus when you sign up through our affiliate link

Best for: Small and medium-sized businesses

Key features: Automated payroll, employee benefits, tax filing, onboarding tools

2. Deel

Best for: Global payroll and contractor payments

Key features: Hire in 150+ countries, EOR services, compliant global payroll

Listing Page: Start with Deel

3. Paylocity

• Best for: U.S.-based teams with advanced HR needs
• Key features: Payroll, benefits, time tracking, modern HCM features
• Listing page:

4. Intuit QuickBooks Payroll

• Overview: Integrated payroll for QuickBooks users.
• Key Features: Same-day direct deposit, automatic tax filing, integration with QuickBooks.
• Best for: Businesses already using QuickBooks
• Website: quickbooks.intuit.com/payroll

5. OnPay

• Overview: Affordable and transparent payroll solution for small businesses.
• Key Features: Unlimited payroll runs, multi-state tax filing, HR tools.
• Best for: Budget-conscious small businesses
• Website: www.onpay.com

6. Multiplier

• Best for: Fast-growing startups hiring remotely
• Key features: Employer of record, payroll automation, multi-country support
• Listing page:

Multiplier

7. Papaya Global

• Overview: All-in-one platform for global payroll and workforce management.
• Key Features: International payroll, compliance, workforce analytics.
• Best for: Companies expanding globally
• Listing page: papayaglobal.com

8. SurePayroll

• Overview: A Paychex company with solutions focused on small businesses and household employers.
• Key Features: Tax filing, mobile payroll, nanny and household payroll.
• Best for: Small businesses and household employers
• Website: www.surepayroll.com

9. Square Payroll

• Overview: Simple payroll solution integrated with Square’s payment ecosystem.
• Key Features: Hourly tracking, direct deposit, contractor and employee payroll.
• Best for: Small retail and hospitality businesses
• Website: squareup.com/payroll

10. Zenefits

• Overview: HR platform with integrated payroll services.
• Key Features: Employee onboarding, benefits, HR compliance, payroll automation.
• Best for: Growing businesses looking for an all-in-one HR solution
• Website: www.zenefits.com

Payroll Companies Comparison Table

🧠 How to Choose the Right Payroll Company

With so many payroll providers on the market, making the right choice requires more than comparing prices. The ideal payroll solution should not only automate pay runs but also adapt to your business’s size, industry, and growth stage. Here’s what to consider:

1. Business Size and Complexity

Start by assessing your current workforce:

• Do you employ salaried staff, hourly workers, or international contractors?
• Are you operating in multiple states or countries?
• Do you anticipate scaling in the next 12–24 months?

💡 Tip: Large organizations might benefit from enterprise-level solutions like ADP or Papaya Global, while small businesses may find Gusto or OnPay more cost-effective and manageable.

2. Tax Compliance and Filing

A top payroll provider should automatically calculate, withhold, and remit payroll taxes at local, state, and federal levels. Features to look for:

• Automated W-2 and 1099 filing
• Real-time tax updates based on jurisdiction
• Year-end reporting and compliance alerts

⚠️ Mistakes in tax filing can result in penalties, audits, and employee dissatisfaction. Choose a provider with a solid compliance track record.

3. Ease of Use and Automation

A great payroll platform should streamline operations without requiring deep accounting knowledge. Consider:

• User-friendly dashboards
• Auto-run payroll settings
• Employee self-service portals
• Mobile app accessibility

🎯 Gusto and QuickBooks Payroll are known for intuitive UIs and quick setup.

4. Contractor and Freelancer Support

In the era of remote and freelance work, contractor payments are critical. Ensure the provider can:

• Handle domestic and international contractor payments
• Generate 1099s automatically
• Provide support for variable or project-based pay cycles

🌍 Platforms like Deel are purpose-built for global contractor management.

5. Benefits and HR Integration

Many payroll systems now integrate benefits administration and HR tools. Look for:

• Built-in onboarding workflows
• Health insurance, 401(k), and PTO tracking
• Integration with HRIS or time-tracking platforms

📌 Zenefits and Paychex offer strong all-in-one HR + payroll functionality.

6. Pricing Structure

Payroll pricing varies by:

• Base monthly fee
• Per-employee/per-contractor fees
• Add-ons for benefits, multi-state filing, or integrations

🧾 OnPay offers flat pricing, while Gusto uses tiered plans based on features. Always check for hidden fees.

7. Customer Support and Reviews

In payroll, timely support is non-negotiable. Evaluate:

• Availability (24/7, business hours, live chat)
• Dedicated account managers for larger clients
• Online documentation and training resources
• Verified reviews on G2, Trustpilot, or Capterra

💬 Look for vendors with a reputation for responsive and helpful customer service—especially during tax season.

8. Scalability and Flexibility

Can the provider grow with your business?

• Support for multiple EINs, locations, or subsidiaries
• International payroll capabilities
• APIs or integrations with your current tech stack

🚀 If you’re planning to scale quickly or expand internationally, providers like Papaya Global or Deel are built to evolve with you.

✅ Summary: Checklist Before You Decide

✔️ Can the provider handle your current and future team structure?
✔️ Does it offer automation, mobile access, and self-service features?
✔️ Are tax filings, benefits, and contractor support built-in?
✔️ Does it fit within your budget, and are fees transparent?
✔️ Are there positive reviews and strong support services?

Choosing the right payroll provider it’s about optimizing people operations, maintaining compliance, and enabling business growth.

Final Thoughts

Choosing the right payroll company is more than a financial decision—it’s a strategic one. The right provider will not only ensure compliance and timely payments but also support your team’s growth, streamline your HR operations, and give you peace of mind.

Discover our new 2025 guide to the best payroll companies in the USA.

Whether you’re a startup hiring your first employees, a growing business expanding across states, or a global company managing international contractors, this list of payroll companies in the USA offers trusted solutions for every need. SUBMIT YOUR HR COMPANY LISTING

Still unsure which provider is best for your situation?
👉 Explore the HR Software for Startups or Request a Free Consultation to get matched with the ideal payroll partner for your business.

Frequently Asked Questions